5 05 2008
Watch a Clip!
Watch a Clip!

This Oscar nominee for Best Live-Action Short Film is an absurdist comedy that careens from one unfunny gag to the next, leaving a hundred-gag pileup in its wake. Set in an Italian middle school, director Andrea Jublin gives us a few peeks into the lives of the stereotypical teens before thrusting his crazed substitute onto the class. This manic juvenile adult leaves the class of students in shock at first, but as he prances around the room like an ADD patient on acid, he forces the students into bizarre behavior to beg for high grades.

Jublin plays Il Supplente so over-the-top that none of the humor hits. The pacing is at a fever pitch from the start, making the audience warn out quickly. In many ways, the often mean-spirited “teacher” reminded me of an Adam Sandler character. Let’s not hope for an American feature length remake. When the supposedly humorous twist arrives, it is no surprise to the audience, because it could only be the logical outcome to the substitute’s actions. The film is trying to embrace the joy of youthful silliness and exuberance, but does so in creating an adult character that doesn’t come off as young-at-heart, but as psychotic. Jublin dedicates the film to “all the people who have problems with conduct.” This class clown has never grown up to discover that his childhood antics were annoying back then, and even more so now that he has grown.

Buy It Now!
Buy It Now!

Buy The 2007 Academy Award Nominated Shorts Now!



Email to a friend »

Use this form to send your friend this post.

2 responses to “IL SUPPLENTE (THE SUBSTITUTE) (2007) (**)”

19 06 2008
smartass (20:02:33) : edit

wtf are u talking about, this is the funniest short movie and best ive ever seen…u must be one of those people that are always serious and have no humor what so ever to find this movie unfunny

20 06 2008
ricksflickspicks (07:06:09) : edit

Comedy is one of the most subjective of all genres. There are funny films for serious people and smartasses and people who find the ridicule of children by an adult who overacts unfunny. So, to each their own.

Leave a comment

You can use these tags : <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>